Revert "Made FlexAttention error on subgraph lowering failure (#140331)"

This reverts commit e68bc76.

Reverted pytorch/pytorch#140331 on behalf of https://github.com/malfet due to Looks like it regressed trunk, see https://hud.pytorch.org/hud/pytorch/pytorch/55f1959fc148240e55a91d7625c750736ea5f2e4/1?per_page=50&name_filter=linux-focal-cuda12.1-py3.10-gcc9-sm86&mergeLF=true ([comment](pytorch/pytorch#140331 (comment)))

Author: pytorchmergebot

test/inductor/test_flex_attention.py

@@ -2965,61 +2965,6 @@ def test_mixed_device_error_message(self):
         with self.assertRaisesRegex(ValueError, expected_error_message):
             flex_attention(query, key, value)
 
-    @supported_platform
-    def test_captured_wrong_device_error_message(self):
-        means = torch.randn(64, 3).cuda()
-        length_scales = torch.logspace(0.001, 0.1, 8)
-
-        def euclidean_dist_pos_embed(score, b, h, q_idx, k_idx):
-            q_pos = means[q_idx]
-            k_pos = means[k_idx]
-            dist = (q_pos - k_pos).pow(2).sum(-1).sqrt()
-            scale = length_scales[h]
-            inv_dist = torch.exp(-dist / scale)
-            return inv_dist * score
-
-        expected_error_message = "Buffers cannot be created"
-
-        q, k, v = (torch.randn(1, 8, 64, 64, device="cuda") for _ in range(3))
-        with self.assertRaisesRegex(RuntimeError, expected_error_message):
-            torch.compile(flex_attention)(q, k, v, score_mod=euclidean_dist_pos_embed)
-
-    @supported_platform
-    def test_cant_lower_error_message(self):
-        # We can't lower a 256-element reduction inside a pointwise reduction
-        means = torch.randn(64, 256).cuda()
-        length_scales = torch.logspace(0.001, 0.1, 8).cuda()
-
-        def euclidean_dist_pos_embed(score, b, h, q_idx, k_idx):
-            q_pos = means[q_idx]
-            k_pos = means[k_idx]
-            dist = (q_pos - k_pos).pow(2).sum(-1).sqrt()
-            scale = length_scales[h]
-            inv_dist = torch.exp(-dist / scale)
-            return inv_dist * score
-
-        expected_error_message = "Buffers cannot be created"
-
-        q, k, v = (torch.randn(1, 8, 64, 64, device="cuda") for _ in range(3))
-        with self.assertRaisesRegex(RuntimeError, expected_error_message):
-            torch.compile(flex_attention)(q, k, v, score_mod=euclidean_dist_pos_embed)
-
-    @supported_platform
-    def test_reduction_unrolled(self):
-        # We can't lower a 256-element reduction inside a pointwise reduction
-        means = torch.randn(S, 3).cuda()
-        length_scales = torch.logspace(0.001, 0.1, H).cuda()
-
-        def euclidean_dist_pos_embed(score, b, h, q_idx, k_idx):
-            q_pos = means[q_idx]
-            k_pos = means[k_idx]
-            dist = (q_pos - k_pos).pow(2).sum(-1).sqrt()
-            scale = length_scales[h]
-            inv_dist = torch.exp(-dist / scale)
-            return inv_dist * score
-
-        self.run_test(euclidean_dist_pos_embed, torch.bfloat16)
-
     @supported_platform
     def test_invalid_block_size(self):
         # Create tensors on different devices

test/inductor/test_torchinductor_opinfo.py

@@ -443,10 +443,6 @@ def wrapper_noop_set_seed(op, *args, **kwargs):
         "atol": 3e-4,
         "rtol": 0.002,
     },
-    ("nn.functional.triplet_margin_with_distance_loss", f16): {
-        "atol": 3e-4,
-        "rtol": 0.003,
-    },
     ("softmax", f16): {"atol": 1e-4, "rtol": 0.02},
     ("polygamma.polygamma_n_0", f32): {"atol": 1e-3, "rtol": 1e-4},
     ("polygamma.polygamma_n_1", f32): {"atol": 1e-3, "rtol": 1e-4},

torch/_higher_order_ops/flex_attention.py

@@ -410,8 +410,8 @@ def flex_attention_functionalize(
     assert isinstance(mask_mod_other_buffers_unwrapped, tuple)
 
     example_vals = (
-        [query_unwrapped.new_zeros(())]
-        + [query_unwrapped.new_zeros((), dtype=torch.int) for _ in range(4)]
+        [torch.zeros((), dtype=query.dtype)]
+        + [torch.zeros((), dtype=torch.int) for _ in range(4)]
         + list(score_mod_other_buffers_unwrapped)
     )
     with ctx.redispatch_to_next() as m:
@@ -710,11 +710,11 @@ def flex_attention_autograd(
         input_requires_grad = any(t.requires_grad for t in (query, key, value))
         if torch.is_grad_enabled() and input_requires_grad:
             example_vals = (
-                query.new_zeros((), requires_grad=input_requires_grad),
-                query.new_zeros((), dtype=torch.int),
-                query.new_zeros((), dtype=torch.int),
-                query.new_zeros((), dtype=torch.int),
-                query.new_zeros((), dtype=torch.int),
+                torch.zeros((), dtype=query.dtype, requires_grad=input_requires_grad),
+                torch.zeros((), dtype=torch.int),
+                torch.zeros((), dtype=torch.int),
+                torch.zeros((), dtype=torch.int),
+                torch.zeros((), dtype=torch.int),
             )
             fw_graph, bw_graph = create_fw_bw_graph(
                 score_mod, example_vals, score_mod_other_buffers
@@ -930,11 +930,11 @@ def trace_flex_attention_backward(
         mask_mod_other_buffers,
     )
 
-    fw_example_vals = [query.new_zeros((), requires_grad=query.requires_grad)] + [
-        query.new_zeros((), dtype=torch.int) for _ in range(4)
-    ]
-    bw_example_vals = fw_example_vals + [query.new_zeros(())]
-    mask_example_vals = [query.new_zeros((), dtype=torch.int) for _ in range(4)]
+    fw_example_vals = [
+        torch.zeros((), dtype=query.dtype, requires_grad=query.requires_grad)
+    ] + [torch.zeros((), dtype=torch.int) for _ in range(4)]
+    bw_example_vals = fw_example_vals + [torch.zeros((), dtype=query.dtype)]
+    mask_example_vals = [torch.zeros((), dtype=torch.int) for _ in range(4)]
     mask_graph = block_mask[-1]
     with TransformGetItemToIndex():
         fw_graph = reenter_make_fx(fw_graph)(*fw_example_vals, *score_mod_other_buffers)

torch/_inductor/ir.py

@@ -1254,10 +1254,8 @@ def fn(index: int) -> OpsValue:
             isinstance(reduction_numel, Integer)
             and V.graph.sizevars.size_hint(reduction_numel)
             < config.unroll_reductions_threshold
-            and (sympy_product(ranges) != 1 or device.type == "cuda")
+            and sympy_product(ranges) != 1
         ):
-            # NB: This works around https://github.com/pytorch/pytorch/issues/140457
-            # since turning reductions into pointwise ops can exacerbate this problem
             return Pointwise.create(
                 device=device,
                 dtype=dst_dtype,

torch/_inductor/kernel/flex_attention.py

@@ -104,40 +104,59 @@ def build_subgraph_buffer(
         args: The args that are passed into the subgraph. Contains both fixed and lifted inputs.
         subgraph: The Subgraph ir for which to produce the output node
     """
-    from ..subgraph_lowering import PointwiseSubgraphLowering
-
-    pw_subgraph = PointwiseSubgraphLowering(
-        subgraph.graph_module, root_graph_lowering=V.graph
-    )
-    with V.set_graph_handler(pw_subgraph):  # type: ignore[arg-type]
-        pw_subgraph.run(*args)
-
-    def convert_output_node_to_buffer(output):
-        if output is None:
-            return None
-        output_buffer = output
-        assert isinstance(output_buffer, TensorBox), (
-            "The output node  for flex attention's subgraph must be a TensorBox, but got: ",
-            type(output_buffer),
-        )
-        assert isinstance(output_buffer.data, StorageBox), (
-            "The output node for the flex attention subgraph must be a StorageBox, but got: ",
-            type(output_buffer),
-        )
-        subgraph_buffer = ComputedBuffer(
-            name=None,
-            layout=FlexibleLayout(
-                device=output_buffer.data.get_device(),
-                dtype=output_buffer.data.get_dtype(),
-                size=output_buffer.data.get_size(),
-            ),
-            data=output_buffer.data.data,  # type: ignore[arg-type]
-        )
-        return subgraph_buffer
-
-    # node.args[0] is either a single element or a list of elements
-    # representing all outputs of the function.
-    return tree_map(convert_output_node_to_buffer, pw_subgraph.graph_outputs)
+    cnt = 0
+    env = {}
+    for node in subgraph.graph_module.graph.nodes:
+        # There are two classes of placeholder inpts that we need
+        # to handle differently. For the first n_scalar_inps inputs
+        # we expect that these placeholders were generated by the make_fx call
+        # in the flex Attention HOP. So we need to create a new placeholder
+        # TensorBox for each of these inputs. For the rest of the inputs we
+        # expect that these are lifted inputs that fill up the '*other_buffers'
+        # tuple and already have corresponding TensorBoxes passed in as args.
+        with V.graph.set_current_node(node):
+            if node.op == "placeholder":
+                env[node] = args[cnt]
+                cnt += 1
+            elif node.op == "call_function":
+                # For call_function we use the default lowerings and pass in the
+                # already created TensorBoxes as args
+
+                args, kwargs = tree_map(
+                    lambda x: env[x] if x in env else x, (node.args, node.kwargs)
+                )
+                env[node] = lowerings[node.target](*args, **kwargs)
+            elif node.op == "output":
+
+                def convert_output_node_to_buffer(output):
+                    if output is None:
+                        return None
+                    output_node = output
+                    output_buffer = env[output_node]
+                    assert isinstance(output_buffer, TensorBox), (
+                        "The output node  for flex attention's subgraph must be a TensorBox, but got: ",
+                        type(output_buffer),
+                    )
+                    assert isinstance(output_buffer.data, StorageBox), (
+                        "The output node for the flex attention subgraph must be a StorageBox, but got: ",
+                        type(output_buffer),
+                    )
+                    subgraph_buffer = ComputedBuffer(
+                        name=None,
+                        layout=FlexibleLayout(
+                            device=output_buffer.data.get_device(),
+                            dtype=output_buffer.data.get_dtype(),
+                            size=output_buffer.data.get_size(),
+                        ),
+                        data=output_buffer.data.data,  # type: ignore[arg-type]
+                    )
+                    return subgraph_buffer
+
+                # node.args[0] is either a single element or a list of elements
+                # representing all outputs of the function.
+                return tree_map(convert_output_node_to_buffer, node.args[0])
+
+    raise ValueError("FlexAttention was passed a subgraph with no output node!")
 
 
 # Inner Triton functions shared by flex_attention & split-k decoding kernels.
@@ -503,7 +522,7 @@ def forward_block_mn(
         ) | indent_except_first(2) }}
 
         if CHECK_BLOCK_BOUNDARY:
-            mask_mod_output = tl.where(offs_n < KV_LEN, mask_mod_output, False)
+            mask_mod_output = tl.where(offs_n < KV_LEN, mask_mod_output, float("-inf"))
         # apply mask for partially unmasked blocks
         post_mod_scores = tl.where(mask_mod_output, post_mod_scores, float("-inf"))
 
@@ -1739,8 +1758,6 @@ def flex_attention_backward(*args, **kwargs):
     joint_placeholder_inps = fwd_placeholder_inps + [
         create_placeholder("grad_score_mod", dtype, device)
     ]
-    # Sometimes we have weird unused nodes here
-    joint_graph.graph_module.graph.eliminate_dead_code()
     joint_subgraph_buffer, *_ = build_subgraph_buffer(
         joint_placeholder_inps + list(score_mod_other_buffers), joint_graph
     )

torch/_inductor/lowering.py

@@ -74,7 +74,7 @@
 
 
 log = logging.getLogger(__name__)
-lowerings: Dict[Callable[..., Any], Callable[..., Any]] = {}
+lowerings: Dict[torch._ops.OpOverload, Callable[..., Any]] = {}
 # Use maybe_layout_constraints to access this dict, we lazily register tag-based layout constraints
 _maybe_layout_constraints: Dict[
     torch._ops.OpOverload, Optional[Callable[..., Any]]

torch/_inductor/subgraph_lowering.py

@@ -13,6 +13,7 @@
 from . import ir
 from .exc import SubgraphLoweringException
 from .ops_handler import SimpleCSEHandler
+from .sizevars import SizeVarAllocator
 from .virtualized import ops, V, WrapperHandler
 
 
@@ -21,11 +22,6 @@
 
 
 class PointwiseSubgraphLowering(torch.fx.Interpreter):
-    """
-    Lowers a pointwise subgraph to a single set of buffers with a separate
-    lowering object. Errors if buffers are created unexpectedly
-    """
-
     graph_outputs: Optional[List[ir.IRNode]]
 
     def __init__(
@@ -37,19 +33,18 @@ def __init__(
         self.graph_outputs = None
         self.root_graph = root_graph_lowering
 
+    @property
+    def sizevars(self) -> SizeVarAllocator:
+        return self.root_graph.sizevars
+
     def mark_buffer_mutated(self, name: str) -> None:
         raise SubgraphLoweringException("Mutations are not supported in this context")
 
     def register_buffer(self, buffer: ir.Buffer) -> str:
         raise SubgraphLoweringException(
-            "Buffers cannot be created while lowering a pointwise subgraph. "
-            "This could be for a good reason (e.g. you're calling an op we can't codegen as a pointwise op), "
-            "but it could also be a bug. Please file a bug report if you think this should be supportable."
+            "Buffer creation is not supported in this context"
         )
 
-    def __getattr__(self, name: str) -> Any:
-        return getattr(self.root_graph, name)
-
     def call_function(
         self,
         target: Callable[[Any], Any],  # type: ignore[override]
@@ -61,11 +56,18 @@ def call_function(
         if target is operator.getitem and isinstance(args[0], (list, tuple, dict)):
             return super().call_function(target, args, kwargs)
 
+        assert isinstance(target, torch._ops.OpOverload)
+
         if target not in lowerings:
             raise SubgraphLoweringException(
                 f"{target} not supported in subgraph, (missing lowering)"
             )
 
+        if torch.Tag.pointwise not in target.tags:
+            raise SubgraphLoweringException(
+                f"Only pointwise operators are supported in this context, but got {target}"
+            )
+
         return lowerings[target](*args, **kwargs)
 
     def output(self, target: str, args: Tuple[Any], kwargs: Dict[str, Any]) -> None:  # type: ignore[override]